Australian Idol 2009 Forums » The Show » Random Idol

Thread: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD


Permlink Replies: 34 - Pages: 3 [ Previous | 1 2 3 | Next ] - Last Post: 21/09/2009 15:30 Last Post By: catsize61 Threads: [ Previous | Next ]
daffodill1


Posts: 172
Joined Forums: 24/08/09
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 13/09/2009 22:00   in response to: haptichands in response to: haptichands
I liked Suzie Q in her day!
Oooops! just told my age! ;)
Cheeky_Girl


Posts: 3,637
Joined Forums: 3/08/07
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 13/09/2009 22:02   in response to: daffodill1 in response to: daffodill1
What Suzie told Sabrina was bad advice.

I just watched it here... shocking.
The judges comments prove its rigged...pmsl
chefcam


Posts: 125
Joined Forums: 9/07/09
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 13/09/2009 23:04   in response to: Cheeky_Girl in response to: Cheeky_Girl
Cheeky_Girl wrote:
What Suzie told Sabrina was bad advice.

I just watched it here... shocking.
The judges comments prove its rigged...pmsl
Yes, Sabrina was terrible!!!! Bad choice too!!!! Linkin Park???? C'mon.....
adam808

Posts: 58
Joined Forums: 13/09/09
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 13/09/2009 23:26   in response to: chefcam in response to: chefcam
i thought tonites show was awesome, i actually noticed the talent in most of these performers and i think suzi did an awesome job, tonight was such a step up compared to last week

and she was a great judge too, gave really good feedback
chefcam


Posts: 125
Joined Forums: 9/07/09
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 13/09/2009 23:51   in response to: daffodill1 in response to: daffodill1
daffodill1 wrote:
I liked Suzie Q in her day!
Oooops! just told my age! ;)
I like to wear rubber...
daffodill1


Posts: 172
Joined Forums: 24/08/09
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 14/09/2009 00:21   in response to: chefcam in response to: chefcam
chefcam wrote:
daffodill1 wrote:
I liked Suzie Q in her day!
Oooops! just told my age! ;)
I like to wear rubber...
On the wheels of your car?
grahamvenessa


Posts: 41
Joined Forums: 28/08/07
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 14/09/2009 08:43   in response to: AmandaMS in response to: AmandaMS
Again, I say, she was a GREAT performance coach, but leave the voice training to someone who has one.
11ACES


Posts: 535
Joined Forums: 14/03/08
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 14/09/2009 09:30   in response to: grahamvenessa in response to: grahamvenessa
I was shocked hearing suzie sing, it was a disaster, she sounded awfull and the advice she gave was even worse, there was maybe 3 true rock songs all night, and then when someone like tim actually does a rock song he turns it into something completley different and destroy it.
I am so dissapointed in last nights show, and what was suzie thinking trying to make them all cry, I nearly spewed my guts when sabrina pulled those depression faces and started to tear up, yes they should feel the music, but to overdramatise so badly was horrible.
Where do they get off calling what happened last night rock night. pffffffft.
buffster


Posts: 17
Joined Forums: 11/03/08
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 14/09/2009 10:17   in response to: 11ACES in response to: 11ACES
11ACES wrote:
I was shocked hearing suzie sing, it was a disaster, she sounded awfull and the advice she gave was even worse,

I beg to differ. The advice she gave was bloody spot on. It was unfortunate she didn't have much voice left after such an awesome show the night before.

So you'd give better advice would you?

As for Sabrina, yes she was woeful. But she always overdramatises, and last night was no different.

11ACES


Posts: 535
Joined Forums: 14/03/08
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 14/09/2009 12:08   in response to: buffster in response to: buffster
buffster wrote:
11ACES wrote:
I was shocked hearing suzie sing, it was a disaster, she sounded awfull and the advice she gave was even worse,

I beg to differ. The advice she gave was bloody spot on. It was unfortunate she didn't have much voice left after such an awesome show the night before.


She was great in her day, but lets be real, its not her day anymore, and hasn't been for many years, so she shouldn't be overcomitting herself to to many performances if the result is coming off sounding the way she did last night.

So you'd give better advice would you?

Well I wouldn't be having them all on the verge of bawling their eyes out on ROCK night for gods sake, every one of them would have been better off without her advice, which they would have felt obliged to follow....

As for Sabrina, yes she was woeful. But she always overdramatises, and last night was no different.

Last night she actually cried during her performance, so it was worse than usual.
yutubetopteensi...


Posts: 293
Joined Forums: 1/08/09
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 14/09/2009 13:26   in response to: Ceeamm in response to: Ceeamm
Suzie was awesome... this group of singers just isnt up to it yet.....

Not a single one of them knows that when you sing rock you dont growl from the throat you lift your cheeks and snarl..... just sing something, lift one cheek and sing it with a snarl and see what I mean, then lift both cheeks and sing it with a snarl.... old Elvis didnt do it just for looks you know, it changes how your voice sounds

was some dreadful song choices... I love Tobes, but what was rock about that song?
I would have preffered him to sing Poison by Alice Cooper....
willowthewisp


Posts: 773
Joined Forums: 6/08/07
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 14/09/2009 14:39   in response to: grahamvenessa in response to: grahamvenessa
The worst performance of the night was from Suzi. She was dreadful.
mob715


Posts: 2
Joined Forums: 14/09/09
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 14/09/2009 15:32   in response to: grahamvenessa in response to: grahamvenessa
Bad call. Suzie Q gave excellent advice. She had amazing insight, not just into RnR, but what each contestant needed internally ie in their heart & head. I'll bet everyone felt they personally benefited greatly from suzie. I mean, how about Scott? "You need to look in the mirror and see yourself liked" Awsome advice.
As for the voices, this is RnR, not some gay melody! They needed to step up to the plate, and they all did and had a full blooded swing.
grahamvenessa


Posts: 41
Joined Forums: 28/08/07
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 15/09/2009 12:45   in response to: mob715 in response to: mob715
Yet again, i will say, Suzie did a great job, as a performance coach, but she screwed with their voices. I know it's Rock, but it takes training or a natural talent to scream properly and none of these kids have the talent for it or were given the chops from Miss Q. For instance, I like Stan's voice, but what was that pittiful sqauk he did mid song, certainly wasn't the scream he was doing in the mentoring segment with Suzie. My thoughts, he damaged his voice and couldn't pull it off on the night. As might I say, neither did Suzie.
daffodill1


Posts: 172
Joined Forums: 24/08/09
Re: Suzie Q's help has not helped, contestants voices were BAD
Posted: 15/09/2009 20:11   in response to: Cheeky_Girl in response to: Cheeky_Girl
Cheeky_Girl wrote:
What Suzie told Sabrina was bad advice.

I just watched it here... shocking.
The judges comments prove its rigged...pmsl

Oh! I know the judges comments are ridiculous alot of the time!
I'm certainly not going to feel sorry for Sabrina though,because Suzie gave her bad advise.
Sabby would have done an annoying job anyway,with or without Suzie Q's advise.

I liked Suzie Q when I was a kid!..I feel the woman knows a bit more about music,than a bunch of amateur contestants on Australian Idol.

Edited by: daffodill1 on 15/09/2009 20:12

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in all forums